Manual Vs. Powered Wheelchair: Which Is Safer?

Numerous considerations come to mind when shopping for a wheelchair, among these being the crucial matter of safety. Both power and manual wheelchairs offer distinct advantages and drawbacks in this regard.

To help you figure out which one suits your safety needs better between a manual vs powered wheelchair, here are some important considerations to keep in mind:

Physical Capabilities

Safely operating a manual wheelchair requires considerable physical stamina and balance. When traveling, you need a good amount of strength, particularly in the upper body, to push yourself forward. Suppose you are physically capable of doing this. In that case, it has noteworthy benefits, including improvements in cardiovascular health and general fitness.

However, if you suffer from any condition causing chronic pain, for instance, arthritis, it would be extremely strenuous and could cause injury. The same applies if you suffer from any condition that affects your ability to move your arms, hands, or upper body.

Terrain and Accessibility Concerns

If you must navigate rough terrain regularly, a power wheelchair offers better safety and flexibility than a manual one. Different models of powered wheelchairs offer distinct features that make them ideal for various terrains.

For instance, the rear-wheel drive model can easily handle gravel or mud and does not struggle with slight gradient changes. On the other hand, front-wheel drives are best for tackling obstacles as high as their axle.

However, manual chairs offer greater flexibility where accessibility is concerned. They are much easier to maneuver in cramped spaces and tackle narrow doorways and hallways. The other electric options, except for mid-wheel power chairs, have a huge turning radius.

It is easier to get them wedged between walls and furniture, which is unsafe, especially if alone. Similarly, if it runs out of power when you are alone, you may be stuck until help arrives.

Level of Independence and Daily Routine

If you live alone and have to run your errands, a power chair is the safer choice. Its energy demands are much less limiting, and the potential to adapt it to your capabilities and preferences is matchless.

Powered wheelchairs come with a wide range of options for control, such as joysticks, touchpads, and even eye-tracking capabilities. Joysticks have various shapes to cater to each user’s needs. Fortunately, you can adapt aspects such as the controller’s positioning, acceleration, deceleration, and speed to your specifications.

However, a manual chair will suffice if you have a caregiver to assist with chores and running errands.

Customizability Potential in Relation to Health Conditions

For users with certain health conditions, the customizability options with powered chairs make them safer. These assistive devices include seat lift, tilt, and recline options; active reach; elevated leg rests; and various standing functions. While these features might sound like fancy additions, they are essential for multiple healthcare concerns.

As an example, if you have edema, the elevated leg rest option allows you to lift your legs to a suitable position to reduce fluid retention. The standing functions come in handy if you suffer from blood pressure issues or have challenges with bowel movements.

Though the manual chair does not offer much in the way of customizability, consider adding a few accessories for convenience. Some great options include a wheelchair cushion to make it comfortable or a wheelchair backpack to add storage.

Take Charge and Avoid the Hazards of Expired Medical Supplies

Determining which type of wheelchair is safer, between manual and power options, boils down to your circumstances. Take time to analyze your lifestyle, travel needs, and health condition before making a choice.